Manchester United lost 2-0 to Chelsea at Stamford Bridge on Saturday 31 October, a third straight defeat that extended their winless run to nine matches in all competitions and left Michael Carrick’s side 17th in the Premier League with seven points from nine games.
Morgan Rogers opened the scoring five minutes after half-time and Cole Palmer converted a penalty in the 64th minute, after Lisandro Martinez had been sent off for two bookings a few minutes apart. United had been the better side before the break and still lost. That is the pattern Carrick has to break, starting with Roma at Old Trafford in the Champions League on Tuesday and Aston Villa at home in the league on Sunday.
In this article

The first half United wasted
United’s first half was their best 45 minutes for weeks. Bruno Fernandes, back in the starting side, blazed over from close range after Bryan Mbeumo broke clear on the counter-attack and cut the ball back. Amad Diallo twice picked Wesley Fofana’s pocket and forced Mike Penders into a near-post save. Matheus Cunha turned in a Harry Maguire header from a corner, only for VAR to rule the goal out for offside.
United’s chances before half-time were worth 1.09 expected goals to Chelsea’s 0.28, according to Opta’s match data, and the full-time figures finished 2.35 to 1.11 in Chelsea’s favour only because the game changed completely after the break. Chelsea had their own frustrations, with Estevao having a goal ruled out in each half and a Moises Caicedo deflection coming back off the post, but a goalless half-time score flattered the home side.
United’s predicted side for Tuesday, covered in our look at Carrick’s 4-2-3-1 lineup against Roma, again leans on Fernandes and Mbeumo to create. Creating isn’t the issue. United made the clearer openings at Stamford Bridge and took none of them, and a side with seven points can’t keep leaving points in the opposition box.
The Rogers goal and the gap in midfield
Five minutes after the restart, Romeo Lavia won the ball in midfield and fed Rogers, who collected it around 35 yards from goal and ran straight at the United defence. He went past Maguire and Martinez without either centre-back stepping in to engage him, then lifted a composed finish over Senne Lammens.
No United midfielder screened the run. Once Lavia’s pass beat the first line of pressure, Rogers had open grass in front of him and two defenders backing off. A midfield that doesn’t close that space forces its centre-backs to defend while retreating, and retreating defenders rarely win that duel against a runner in form. Rogers, Chelsea’s record signing, had been quiet in the first half.
Chelsea, who had lost their previous two matches and were without top league scorer Joao Pedro, didn’t need to be at their best after that. Xabi Alonso’s side managed the game, and the side we previewed in Chelsea’s predicted lineup against Man Utd finished the afternoon fourth in the table on 16 points.
Two bookings that ended the contest
Martinez was booked for a foul on Rogers as he tried to stop another run. A few minutes later, defending an Estevao corner, he shoved an arm into Fofana’s face at the far post. VAR sent referee Peter Bankes to the pitchside screen, and he showed a second yellow card and awarded a penalty. Palmer scored it, sending the ball under Lammens, for his 50th Premier League goal for Chelsea in his 105th appearance. Only Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink and Diego Costa have reached that mark for the club in fewer games.
Carrick didn’t hide from the moment’s weight. “It’s a big moment in the game,” he said. “The second goal and losing a man at that stage had a big influence on it, for sure.” With ten men and 26 minutes left, United’s only late opening was a Mbeumo volley that Penders tipped onto the woodwork in added time.
It was Martinez’s second Premier League red card of 2026. Whatever the provocation in a crowded penalty area, a senior defender on a booking can’t give the officials that decision to make, and his suspension now removes him from the Villa game on Sunday, the league match United can least afford to treat as a free hit.
Seventeenth, and the run behind it
United have one win, four draws and four defeats from nine league games, with ten goals scored and 15 conceded. They sit 17th, level on seven points with Crystal Palace in 18th and above the relegation zone on goal difference alone.
United lost 4-1 at Como in the Champions League and 3-0 at home to Bournemouth in the league before Saturday, so the Chelsea loss was a third defeat in a row, with nine goals conceded and one scored across the three games. Nine matches without a win in all competitions is the club’s longest such run since 1984, according to Opta. Their only league win this season came against Ipswich Town.
Former United manager Erik ten Hag said on Monday that relegation is “certainly possible” for United in a league this strong. Carrick, at his own press conference on Monday, set questions about his future aside and pointed to the Roma match. How his record compares with Solskjaer and Amorim is in our look at Carrick’s record at United.
What comes next for Carrick
United host Roma on Tuesday night in the Champions League, where they have three points from three matches, then host Aston Villa in the Premier League on Sunday. Martinez is available in Europe but suspended for the Villa game after his two bookings.








Discussion
What is your take? Join the discussion below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.