Manchester United ended a nine-match winless run with a 3-2 comeback win over Roma at Old Trafford on Tuesday night, Matheus Cunha scoring twice in three minutes late on and then being sent off in stoppage time of a Champions League Matchday 4 game United had trailed 2-0 inside 17 minutes.

Man Utd player ratings board for the 3-2 win over Roma, Cunha 9 out of 10, Fernandes 8, Lacey 8

How the comeback happened

Roma, set up in the 3-4-2-1 shown in our Roma lineup preview for this fixture, were ahead after 11 minutes. Rodrigo Mora switched play to the unmarked Matias Soule, who took a touch and finished into the bottom corner. Six minutes later Ayden Heaven handled inside the box and Donyell Malen converted the penalty, sending Senne Lammens the wrong way. United were booed off at half-time, and Carlos Baleba then went off injured early in the second half.

The game turned on a penalty Cunha won. Bruno Fernandes saw his first attempt saved by Devis Vasquez, but the kick was retaken for encroachment and Fernandes scored at the second attempt on 58 minutes. Bryan Mbeumo then struck both posts with one shot, and United levelled on 83 minutes when Fernandes crossed, Leonardo Balerdi missed his clearance and Cunha finished from close range. Three minutes later Cunha scored again, a near-post finish from Shea Lacey’s pass, before a second yellow card at 90+1 minutes left United to finish the game with ten men. The ratings below cover the United side Michael Carrick named in our Man Utd lineup piece for the Roma game, in their 4-2-3-1 shape.

Goalkeeper and defence

Senne Lammens, 7/10: Beaten from the penalty spot after diving the wrong way, but his low save from Malen before half-time kept the deficit at two and gave the comeback a platform.

Leny Yoro, 6/10: Started in a back four that was pulled apart twice in the opening 17 minutes, then settled as United pushed Roma back in the second half.

Harry Maguire, 6/10: His loose touch in the box started the sequence that ended in Heaven’s handball and Roma’s penalty. Booked on 78 minutes and replaced by Matthijs de Ligt on 88 minutes, after a stronger second half in both boxes.

Ayden Heaven, 5/10: Handled to concede the penalty that put United 2-0 down, was booked on 70 minutes and was replaced by Lisandro Martinez on 75 minutes. A difficult night for the young defender, who was part of a back line that improved after the break.

Diogo Dalot, 5/10: Almost gifted Malen a third goal in the first half and spent much of the opening period chasing Roma’s wing-backs. More secure once United were on the front foot.

Midfield

Carlos Baleba, 5/10: United’s midfield was overrun in the opening spell when Roma scored twice, and his evening ended early when injury forced him off on 51 minutes, with Youri Tielemans coming on.

Kobbie Mainoo, 5/10: His midfield turnover started the move for Soule’s opener. Worked hard to get United playing forward after half-time, but the costly early error sets his mark.

Bruno Fernandes, 8/10: Booked after 20 minutes in a scuffle with Soule, then led the comeback. Scored the retaken penalty on 58 minutes and crossed for the equaliser before going off on 88 minutes, replaced by Mason Mount.

Attack

Amad Diallo, 6/10: Part of a front four that created little in the first half and much more after the penalty. Replaced by Lacey on 75 minutes, a change that produced the winning goal.

Matheus Cunha, 9/10: Won the penalty that started the comeback, equalised on 83 minutes after Balerdi’s missed clearance and scored the winner three minutes later from Lacey’s pass. Two yellow cards, the second at 90+1 minutes, meant he was sent off before full-time. The best and most careless United player on the same night.

Bryan Mbeumo, 7/10: Led the line and came closest to a second United goal before Cunha’s double, striking both posts with one shot in the spell when Roma began to drop deeper and deeper.

Substitutes

Youri Tielemans, 7/10 (on 51 minutes for Baleba): Came on for the injured Baleba and helped United control the second half, keeping the ball moving as the pressure on Roma built.

Lisandro Martinez, 6/10 (on 75 minutes for Heaven): Introduced for the booked Heaven and was part of the defence that held on through the closing minutes with ten men.

Shea Lacey, 8/10 (on 75 minutes for Amad): Fifteen minutes on the pitch were enough to set up the winner, his pass finding Cunha for the near-post finish on 86 minutes.

Matthijs de Ligt, 6/10 (on 88 minutes for Maguire): A late introduction who helped United see out stoppage time after Cunha’s sending-off.

Mason Mount, 6/10 (on 88 minutes for Fernandes): Replaced the captain for the final minutes and helped close the game out in midfield.

What it means

The win is United’s first in ten games in all competitions and ends the nine-match winless run examined in our look at what Chelsea exposed about Carrick’s side on Saturday. It doesn’t fix the defensive problems Roma exposed in the first 17 minutes. Cunha’s red card brings a European ban, not a domestic one, so he’s free for Sunday’s visit of Aston Villa (our predicted Man Utd lineup). For Carrick, 54 days without a win ended at Old Trafford from 2-0 down.

Luca Marchetti is a football writer covering Serie A and European football, specialising in tactical analysis and the transfer market.