Updated 19:10 UK: confirmed lineups are in.

Lisandro Martinez has been dropped for Manchester United’s Champions League tie with Roma at Old Trafford (kick-off 20:00 UK time tonight, Tuesday 3 November). Michael Carrick replaces him with Ayden Heaven, three days after Martinez was sent off in the 2-0 defeat at Chelsea. It is one of two changes: Kobbie Mainoo comes in for Andrey Santos in midfield.

Man Utd confirmed XI (4-2-3-1 shape by the names listed)

Lammens

Yoro

Maguire

Heaven

Dalot

Baleba

Mainoo

Amad

Fernandes

Cunha

Mbeumo

Manchester United XI: Lammens, Yoro, Maguire, Heaven, Dalot, Baleba, Mainoo, Amad, Fernandes, Cunha, Mbeumo.

Subs: Darlow, Heaton, Amass, De Ligt, Martinez, Mazraoui, Andrey Santos, Mount, T Fletcher, Tielemans, Lacey, Zirkzee.

Roma XI: Vasquez, Rensch, Balerde, Hermoso, Cristante, Mancini, De Roon, Wesley, Soule, Rodrigo Mora, Malen.

Roma subs: De Marzi, Koulierakis, Ndicka, Castro, Molina, Pisilli, De Nunzio, Lulli, Ghilardi.

Who is missing

Player Status
Lisandro Martinez On the bench after Saturday’s red card; dropped for Heaven
Marcus Rashford Not in the matchday squad; listed by the FPL app with a hip injury and a 75% chance of playing
Benjamin Sesko Not in the matchday squad; shin injury, no return date in the FPL app
Luke Shaw Not in the matchday squad; injured, no return date in the FPL app

Roma’s only defeat this season came against Real Madrid in the Champions League, when they led with seven minutes to go. Tonight’s other English tie is Barcelona v Aston Villa.

What we predicted

The earlier predicted lineup and team news, published before the official teams were announced:

Manchester United host Roma at Old Trafford on Tuesday night (3 November, 20:00 GMT) in Champions League Matchday 4, with Michael Carrick nine matches without a win in all competitions and Benjamin Sesko ruled out until at least January with a shin injury, so Bryan Mbeumo is set to lead the line in a 4-2-3-1.

United have three points from their first three league phase games. They beat Sabah 4-0 on Matchday 1 and have lost to Atletico Madrid and Como since, while Roma have four points and arrive unbeaten in Serie A, with seven wins and three draws from ten games. The Chelsea match on Saturday was the game United’s board backed Carrick to steady things in, as covered in the report on Carrick staying in charge for the trip to Stamford Bridge, and the 2-0 defeat there has raised the stakes again. The Matchday 4 lineup series also covers Barcelona’s predicted XI against Aston Villa and the PSG lineup at Villarreal.

The team news that shapes the XI

Sesko’s absence is the biggest single problem. The striker has not played since September and is out until at least January, which leaves Carrick without a recognised centre-forward. Mbeumo, who led the line at times at Chelsea, is the obvious stand-in, with Joshua Zirkzee, who replaced Amad Diallo late on at Stamford Bridge, the option from the bench.

The left-back position is short as well. Luke Shaw and Patrick Dorgu are both out until after the November international break, and Manuel Ugarte remains a long-term absentee in midfield. Marcus Rashford missed the Chelsea game with a hip problem and is not expected to return on Tuesday. Amad started at Chelsea and played 77 minutes, and United will assess him before kick-off.

Carrick does get some good news: Lisandro Martinez is available. Martinez was sent off at Chelsea after two yellow cards within minutes of each other, the second for raising an arm into Wesley Fofana’s face, which also gave away the penalty Cole Palmer scored, but that suspension applies to domestic matches only, so he can play in Europe.

Manchester United v Roma team news board showing Sesko, Shaw, Dorgu and Ugarte out, Rashford and Amad as doubts, Martinez available, and the Matchday 4 numbers

The predicted XI

Carrick used a 4-2-3-1 at Chelsea, with Carlos Baleba and Andrey Santos in the double pivot, and the shape is unlikely to change for Roma. What should change is the personnel in the middle. Youri Tielemans was an unused substitute at Stamford Bridge, so he is fresh, and his passing gives United a way to play through Roma’s first line of pressure instead of going long to Mbeumo. Baleba keeps his place as the holder, Kobbie Mainoo, who replaced him after 58 minutes at Chelsea, is the alternative, and Santos drops to the bench.

Manchester United predicted XI (4-2-3-1)

Mbeumo

Cunha

Fernandes

Amad

Baleba

Tielemans

Mazraoui

Martinez

Maguire

Dalot

Lammens

Senne Lammens continues in goal. In front of him, Noussair Mazraoui returns at left-back after being an unused substitute at Chelsea, Diogo Dalot goes back to his natural side at right-back, and Leny Yoro, who started at right-back at Stamford Bridge, drops out. Harry Maguire partners Martinez in the middle.

Why Fernandes has to play closer to the ball

The clearest problem at Chelsea was the space in front of United’s defence. Morgan Rogers scored the opening goal five minutes after half-time by running through the centre of the pitch, and neither centre-back stepped out to meet him while the two midfielders were pulled apart. Bruno Fernandes spent long spells of that game high up the pitch, close to Chelsea’s back line, which left Baleba and Santos to build the play on their own and left nobody between the lines to receive the first forward pass.

In this XI, Tielemans takes the first pass from the centre-backs and plays forward early, Baleba holds his position instead of chasing the ball, and Fernandes drops ten yards deeper to receive on the turn rather than waiting for the ball to reach him. When United lose possession, Matheus Cunha tucks in from the left to make a three in midfield and Dalot holds his position, so the back four is not left defending the full width of the pitch on its own. Roma’s midfield will press in numbers under Gian Piero Gasperini, and United’s best route out is a midfielder who can take the ball under pressure, which is why Fernandes cannot be left standing on the last line.

The calls Carrick cannot get wrong

The Martinez decision is the hardest one. He is available, he is United’s best left-sided passer out of defence, and dropping him three days after a red card would read as a punishment rather than a football decision. Matthijs de Ligt is the alternative: he was an unused substitute at Chelsea, so he is fresh, and he partners Maguire if Carrick decides he cannot trust Martinez in a game of this size. We think Martinez starts, because United need his passing against Roma’s press more than they need to make an example of him.

The second call is Amad. If he does not pass fit, Mason Mount, who came on for Cunha at Chelsea, is the standby on the right of the three, with Mbeumo staying up front rather than moving wide. Moving Mbeumo to the wing and starting Zirkzee would weaken both positions at once, and Carrick has already seen that version of this attack at Stamford Bridge, where Zirkzee’s late appearance changed little.

A win on Tuesday takes United to six points and above Roma in the league phase table. A defeat leaves them on three points from four games, with the next Champions League fixture away to Sporting CP on Wednesday 25 November.

The lineup in full

Manchester United (4-2-3-1): Lammens; Dalot, Maguire, Martinez, Mazraoui; Baleba, Tielemans; Amad, Fernandes, Cunha; Mbeumo.

Arjun Rao is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactical breakdowns, transfer analysis and the numbers behind the game.