Manchester United’s 1-1 draw with ten-man Tottenham at Old Trafford on Saturday has pushed Michael Carrick’s future to the top of the agenda. The hosts led through Bryan Mbeumo’s 73rd-minute strike, were handed a man advantage when Rodrigo Bentancur saw red five minutes later, and still let it slip as Dominic Solanke headed home in stoppage time. The boos that greeted the final whistle, the six points from six league games and the club’s worst start to a season in 40 years have left the pressure gauge on Carrick at its highest yet.
No decision is imminent, but the question is already being asked around the club and in the stands: if United do make a change, who would they turn to? Here are three plausible candidates, with the honest case for and against each.

Fabian Hürzeler: the Brighton blueprint
The case for Hürzeler is the strongest on paper. The German remains in charge at Brighton, and the Seagulls sit third in the Premier League after a start that included a 3-0 demolition of the champions Arsenal at the Amex in September, with one of the division’s most prolific attacks in the early weeks of the season. The football is front-foot, high-energy and possession-based, exactly the profile United’s hierarchy have historically said they admire.
Hürzeler is young, tactically modern and proven in this league, which is precisely why United would have to pay a fortune to get him. Brighton are a club moving in the right direction, and there is no indication he is looking to leave. The compensation alone would be enormous, and prising a manager out of a stable, well-run rival mid-season is the hardest recruitment job in football. He is the outstanding candidate, but also the least available.
Kieran McKenna: the available architect
McKenna is out of work and available right now. The 40-year-old stepped down as Ipswich Town manager in June after five seasons that brought three promotions in four years, including two returns to the Premier League. He has said he wants time away from football to spend with his family, but he was already linked with the Fulham vacancy before he had even cleared his desk, according to Fox Sports, which suggests his name is circulating at the top level.
The appeal for United is obvious. McKenna served as an assistant coach at Old Trafford from 2016 to 2021, so he knows the club’s culture and its squad. His Ipswich teams were meticulously coached, and his record of building a club from League One to the top flight shows he can construct something from the ground up. The drawback is that he chose a sabbatical, so United would have to persuade him back into the dugout sooner than he planned, and he has never managed a club of this size, with this level of scrutiny and this volume of noise.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer: the nostalgic return
Solskjaer’s name will always be mentioned in this conversation. The Norwegian is a free agent after leaving Besiktas in August 2025, and he was among the leading contenders for the Ipswich job this summer before the Tractor Boys appointed Gary O’Neil, according to CentreDevils. His record in his previous Old Trafford spell includes second and third-place Premier League finishes and a Europa League final, which puts his league peak alongside anything any full-time manager has managed at the club since Sir Alex Ferguson retired.
The emotional logic is clear: a club legend who restores unity, simplifies the football and gets the crowd on side. But there is a complication. When United needed an interim in January, they spoke to Solskjaer and chose Carrick instead, according to reports cited by SportBible. Returning now to the man who was passed over for the current incumbent would be an admission of a mistake, and it would invite the question of what has changed since January. It would feel like a step back.
Which way would United lean?
Of the three, McKenna is the only one who is both attainable and a genuine long-term project, though his sabbatical complicates it. Hürzeler is the best manager of the three but the hardest to extract. Solskjaer is the easiest to sell to the stands but the hardest to justify to a board that passed on him nine months ago. None of them is a clean answer.
talkSPORT’s Gabby Agbonlahor has suggested Antonio Conte and Eddie Howe could be waiting in the wings if the job becomes available, per talkSPORT, and the shortlist will certainly be longer than three names. For now, Carrick remains in the job, and his focus is on stopping the slide before Atletico Madrid away on Tuesday. But after the draw that left Carrick on the brink and the talking points from the El Sackico sack race, the conversation about what comes next is only going to get louder, particularly with Leeds away following the midweek trip.







Discussion
Should he stay or go? Tell us what you think.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.