The £19m Winger Liverpool and Tottenham Want for Free: Inside Kaoru Mitoma’s Brighton Contract Bombshell

Kaoru Mitoma is about to become the most valuable free agent in Premier League history — and Liverpool and Tottenham are already circling. The 29-year-old Brighton winger, out of contract in June 2027, has told the Seagulls he will not sign a new deal, triggering a transfer scramble that TEAMtalk first reported on 2 October and BBC Sport’s gossip column carried the same day: both clubs are monitoring the Japan international over a possible January move. This is the story of the autumn — and our tactical verdict on where Mitoma actually fits.

The Bombshell: Contract Talks Stall, the Big Boys Circle

The news landed on 2 October like a grenade in the Premier League’s transfer ecosystem. TEAMtalk reported that Liverpool and Tottenham are monitoring Kaoru Mitoma’s situation at Brighton, with both clubs able to make contact over a pre-contract agreement at the start of 2027 — and, per BBC Sport’s gossip round-up, a possible cut-price January move is not off the table either. The Japan winger, 29, is into the final 20 months of the contract he signed in October 2023, and sources close to the player say he has decided against extending his stay on the south coast.

Let that sink in. Brighton signed Mitoma from Kawasaki Frontale for around £2.6 million in 2021. He is now valued at approximately £19 million by Transfermarkt and earns roughly £80,000 a week, making him one of the highest-paid players in the club’s history. If the standoff holds, the Seagulls face the familiar binary: sell in January at a reduced fee, or watch their most marketable attacker walk out for nothing in June 2027.

Liverpool hold what multiple outlets describe as a long-standing interest — their recruitment staff rated Mitoma highly before his move from Japan — while Tottenham’s interest carries a human connection that makes it genuinely dangerous: Roberto De Zerbi, the manager who turned Mitoma into a Premier League star, now sits in the Spurs dugout. As we covered in our deep dive on the chaos engulfing Tottenham, De Zerbi’s rock-bottom side desperately needs proven wide quality. Bayern Munich, Atletico Madrid, Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester United have all been linked too — but Liverpool and Spurs are the named frontrunners.

Why Brighton Could Lose Their £80k-a-Week Star for Nothing

To understand the standoff, rewind to May. Mitoma suffered a hamstring injury that ended his 2025-26 season and, cruelly, ruled him out of the World Cup — the tournament the 29-year-old had spent four years building towards. He is yet to make a single appearance in the 2026-27 campaign, missing Brighton’s first eight competitive matches while on a cautious rehabilitation programme, and until he returns to regular action and looks like himself, the frenzy will stay at “monitoring” rather than “bidding”.

Fabian Hürzeler, meanwhile, was previously confident of tying his winger down. The Brighton head coach confirmed back in March that discussions had taken place and expressed hope Mitoma would commit — but talks have since stalled completely, and several Champions League clubs reportedly made contact with the player’s camp during his summer rehabilitation to explore a 2027 free transfer. The decision, as one report put it, is “edging towards formalisation”.

There is a delicious irony here. Mitoma’s extension in October 2023 was the deal that was supposed to protect Brighton’s asset — the Premier League’s own announcement confirmed the four-year term running to June 2027, with De Zerbi declaring “Kaoru is our top player” on the club’s official website. Three years later, that same contract is a ticking clock.

Liverpool’s Case: Iraola’s Left-Wing Headache

Start with Liverpool, because Andoni Iraola’s need is the most urgent. Cody Gakpo withdrew from the Netherlands squad with an ankle injury, Alexander Isak is nursing the thigh problem that forced him out of Sweden duty, and while Florian Wirtz is purring, the left wing suddenly looks thin. In our predicted Liverpool XI for the Manchester City clash, we had Victor Muñoz and Bradley Barcola covering the flanks — exciting, but raw.

Mitoma, by contrast, is the finished article: 135 Brighton appearances, 27 goals and 21 assists, a winger who has terrorised Premier League full-backs for four seasons. In Iraola’s 4-2-3-1, he slots straight into the left-sided role Gakpo vacates — an inverted right-footer who carries at 34 km/h and creates from wide overloads. Crucially, he costs nothing in a transfer fee if Liverpool wait until 2027, or a fraction of his value in January.

The tactical fit runs deeper. Iraola’s system demands wingers who can isolate full-backs in 1v1s — Mitoma does that, and his off-ball running (21.5 sprints per 90 minutes at his peak, per Brighton’s own analytics) suits the Spaniard’s vertical, transition-heavy football. At 29, he is also the veteran presence a young dressing room needs: Rio Ngumoha is 17, Muñoz is learning on the job, and Barcola is still adapting.

Embed from Getty Images

Tottenham’s Case: The De Zerbi Reunion

But Tottenham’s case might be even more compelling — because it is personal. Mitoma played the finest football of his career under Roberto De Zerbi at Brighton. The Italian’s 4-2-3-1 was tailor-made for an inverted winger who wants to run with the ball, and De Zerbi’s public adoration (“Kaoru is our top player”) was the foundation of a relationship that produced Mitoma’s 2022-23 breakout.

Spurs, as everyone knows, are in the gutter. Bottom of the table, two points from five games, two goals scored — the full horror show we detailed in our tactical autopsy of De Zerbi’s nightmare start. What they lack most is a winger who can beat a man and create something from nothing. Mitoma is the antidote: a proven Premier League creator who already speaks De Zerbi’s footballing language fluently.

There is a catch, of course, and it is a big one: will De Zerbi still be in the Spurs dugout by the time any deal happens? The Italian is under severe pressure, with Arne Slot’s name circulating as a potential replacement and an ‘El Sackico’ against Manchester United looming on 10 October that could define his tenure. If Spurs sack the man Mitoma would be reuniting with, the entire logic of the move collapses. That uncertainty is Liverpool’s greatest ally.

The Tactical Fit: What Mitoma Actually Does on a Pitch

Strip away the transfer noise and Mitoma remains one of the most distinctive wingers in Europe. His superpower is ball-carrying: he clocked a top speed above 34 km/h in his peak Brighton season, and he hunts the ball, driving at full-backs from deep and opening the half-spaces that modern 4-2-3-1s are built to exploit.

His end product is underrated, too. Seven of his first 12 Brighton goals put the team in the lead — match-winners away at Arsenal in the League Cup, at home to Liverpool in the FA Cup, twice against Bournemouth. He scores the trademark inverted-winger curler, but also headers, lobs from out-to-in runs and slaloming solo goals. For Liverpool, that is a second goalscorer from the left flank to complement Isak’s central threat; for Tottenham, it is the kind of individual brilliance that turns 0-0s into 1-0s.

Defensively, he is no passenger either. De Zerbi’s Brighton pressed in organised, aggressive waves, and Mitoma’s work rate was central to it — a non-negotiable for both Iraola’s Liverpool and any De Zerbi side. The one tactical question is positional: Mitoma is at his best on the left, which means he competes directly with Gakpo at Liverpool and Spurs’ left-sided options rather than solving the right-wing vacancy both clubs also have.

The Five Risks Nobody Wants to Talk About

1. The hamstring. Mitoma has not played a competitive minute this season. The May hamstring injury that ended his campaign and cost him a World Cup is the kind of soft-tissue problem that recurs in explosive wingers approaching 30 — and there is no medical certainty yet.

2. The age curve. He turns 30 in May 2027. Wingers built on searing pace and 1v1 explosiveness historically decline sharply after 30, and a four-year deal for that profile is a genuine gamble, even on a free transfer.

3. The wage structure. Free transfers are never free. Mitoma is one of Brighton’s top earners already, and his camp will demand a significant uplift plus a signing-on fee — the true cost of a “free” deal could easily exceed £40 million over four years.

4. The competition. Liverpool and Tottenham are the named frontrunners, but Bayern Munich, Atletico Madrid, Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester United have all been linked. A free-agent bidding war is fought in wages, and Premier League clubs do not always win those.

5. The De Zerbi variable. Tottenham’s entire pitch rests on the reunion — but if Spurs sack their struggling manager before January, Mitoma’s primary reason for choosing north London evaporates overnight.

Embed from Getty Images

Verdict: Where Does Mitoma Actually End Up?

Here is the uncomfortable truth for Brighton: they have already lost. The only question is whether they lose him for £15-20 million in January or for nothing in June 2027. The player’s mind is made up, the Champions League vultures are circling, and every week without an extension strengthens the suitors’ hands.

Our call? Liverpool. The logic is colder and cleaner: a settled project, a defined role in Iraola’s 4-2-3-1, genuine left-wing need created by the Gakpo and Isak injuries, and none of the managerial chaos hanging over Spurs. A cut-price January deal — somewhere around the £19 million Transfermarkt valuation — solves Liverpool’s depth crisis immediately while denying rivals a free agent in the summer. Tottenham’s De Zerbi reunion is the romantic option, but romance does not survive a relegation battle.

One thing is certain: the January window just got its first blockbuster storyline. The £2.6 million bargain from Kawasaki is about to become the most fought-over signature in English football — and Brighton will watch it happen with almost no control over the outcome.