Erling Haaland turned to the Norway bench in the 67th minute in Porto, gestured that he was done, and limped off — and for ten terrifying minutes, Manchester City’s entire season flashed before everyone’s eyes. Then Stale Solbakken spoke, and the story flipped on its head: the withdrawal was pre-planned, the product of a “heart-to-heart” about load management, and the Viking may be fine for Anfield after all. But the scare exposed something deeper — the most important tactical question in English football right now: what exactly does Enzo Maresca’s machine look like without its most lethal part?

The 67th-Minute Scare in Porto

With the score locked at 1-1 in the Nations League clash at the Estadio do Dragao — Ajer’s 36th-minute stunner cancelled out by Cancelo’s instant reply — Haaland made the gesture no City fan ever wants to see. He turned toward the dugout, indicated he could not continue, and was replaced by Crystal Palace’s Jorgen Strand Larsen. Cameras caught him limping. Twelve minutes later, Ramos poked home the winner that sealed Portugal’s quarter-final place, and the post-match conversation in England was about only one thing: the Norwegian’s body, six days before the biggest game of City’s season.

The alarm was understandable. This was Haaland’s fourth match in eleven days — 90 minutes in the 3-2 win over Denmark, 90 more in the home defeat to Portugal, another full game in the 2-1 loss to Wales, and now 65 minutes of a bruising night in Porto. That is more than five and a half hours of international football across three countries in under two weeks for a 26-year-old who had already gone goalless in two straight Norway games. When The Times led with “Haaland limps off,” the Anfield trip on October 11 suddenly looked very different.

Embed from Getty Images

For the full tactical story of the night itself — Ramos’s winner, Conceicao’s red card, and the ten-man Portuguese stand — see our tactical breakdown of Portugal 2-1 Norway.

Solbakken’s Load-Management Confession

Then came the twist. Speaking to Norwegian broadcaster TV2 after the game, Stale Solbakken dismantled the injury narrative piece by piece. The substitution, he said, had been agreed in advance — the product of a frank Saturday conversation about minutes, fatigue, and the brutal calendar facing Champions League players who had no summer break.

“We had hopes of 60 minutes after the conversation we had yesterday,” Solbakken told TV2. “And he managed 65 minutes.” As Fantasy Football Scout detailed, the Norway boss revealed he had held the same conversation with five or six overplayed stars, agreeing that each would play “until he felt he couldn’t contribute anymore” — with the 60-minute mark as the rough guide. Strand Larsen had been warming up “extremely aggressively” precisely so he would not be thrown in cold. And perhaps most tellingly: Haaland received no treatment after taking his seat, and there was no sign of a limp when he left the stadium.

Solbakken even praised what the 65 minutes had produced: “He terrorised their centre-backs, which allowed us to sustain longer spells of possession in the first half because both centre-backs were occupied.” That is the Haaland paradox in one sentence — even a load-managed, goalless Haaland warps the entire defensive structure around him. Which is exactly why the scare, real or not, matters so much for what comes next.

City’s Haaland Dependency: The Numbers

Strip away the noise and the arithmetic is stark. Haaland has seven goals in seven games across all competitions this season, including five in five Premier League appearances. City have a perfect five-from-five league record. Those two facts are not a coincidence — they are the same fact wearing different clothes. Maresca’s 4-3-3, for all its positional sophistication, has been funnelled through one 6ft 5in focal point all season.

Now look at the casualty list stacking up behind him. Phil Foden is suspended for the Anfield trip after his red card. Nico O’Reilly withdrew from the England squad and travelled home for “further assessments,” with Rico Lewis drafted in as his replacement. Antoine Semenyo is also a doubt. Add a Haaland scare — even a managed one — and suddenly the champions’ attacking depth looks alarmingly thin for the most hostile away trip of the season, with PSG arriving at the Etihad just three days later. This is also, remember, City’s first game since the Premier League confirmed the club guilty on 114 of 115 financial-breach charges, with an appeal lodged on October 1. The noise around the club has never been louder; the margin for error on the pitch has never been smaller.

Man City injury and suspension doubts ahead of the Liverpool vs Man City trip to Anfield: Haaland, Foden, O'Reilly and Semenyo

That is the context in which the contingency blueprint stops being a theoretical exercise. If Haaland’s body — or simply his minutes — needs protecting across the Anfield-PSG double-header, Maresca needs a functioning strikerless system ready to deploy. The good news for City fans: the raw materials are already in the building.

The Strikerless Blueprint: How Maresca Rebuilds the Attack

The first principle of a post-Haaland City is the one Pep Guardiola’s sides proved a decade ago: you do not replace the No.9, you redistribute him. Haaland’s unique value is not just goals — it is gravity. Both centre-backs stay occupied, the defensive line drops five yards deeper, and the half-spaces open for everyone else. Remove him and Maresca must manufacture that gravity through movement instead of mass.

Tactical diagram comparing Man City's 4-3-3 shape with Haaland as a fixed No.9 against the strikerless 4-2-4 contingency with a false nine

The most natural solution is the false nine. Semenyo, if fit, is the prototype: a powerful, mobile forward who can drop into the No.10 zone, drag a centre-back out, and let the wingers run beyond him into the vacated space. Behind him, Enzo Fernandez — who opened his City account earlier this season — becomes the late-arriving third man, crashing the box from midfield the way the system has always demanded of its eights. The shape morphs from 4-3-3 into a fluid 4-2-4 in possession, with the rest-defence of the double pivot holding the fort behind it.

Embed from Getty Images

The second principle is width with intent. Without a penalty-box predator, crosses become low-percentage lottery tickets; City would instead lean on wide overloads and cutbacks, the classic strikerless diet. The wingers invert, the full-backs provide the overlap, and the ball is worked into the half-spaces for cutbacks across the six-yard box — the exact zone Haaland usually attacks, now flooded by three runners instead of one finisher. It is less efficient per chance, but it generates more chances, and against a Liverpool side that presses as aggressively as Andoni Iraola’s — as covered in our Liverpool international-break takeaways — the ability to play through the press with a dropping forward rather than over it to a target man could be a genuine tactical advantage, not just damage limitation.

The third principle is set pieces and second balls. Take away the league’s best header of a cross and dead balls lose their primary weapon — near-post flick-ons, rehearsed short-corner routines, the centre-backs as aerial targets. Marginal gains, but Anfield games are decided in the margins.

Bar chart showing Erling Haaland's minutes across Norway's four Nations League games: 90, 90, 90 and 65 minutes

None of this is fantasy. Maresca inherited a squad built by a club that spent the Guardiola years proving a team can win everything without a recognised striker. The positional-play principles — the 3-2-5 build-up, the five vertical corridors, the obsession with the half-space — are striker-agnostic. Haaland made them devastating; he did not make them function.

What It Means for Liverpool vs Man City at Anfield

Here is where the 67th-minute scare meets the calendar. Liverpool vs Manchester City on October 11 is not just a top-of-the-table clash — it is City’s first match as a convicted club, at the ground where their title rivals are most ferocious, with a Champions League night against PSG 72 hours later. If Haaland starts, the entire episode becomes a footnote about smart load management. If he does not — or if Maresca protects him with an hour from the bench — the strikerless blueprint gets its ultimate stress test.

Iraola’s Liverpool will smell blood either way. A City without Haaland is a City that cannot go long under pressure; every goal kick becomes a short-build invitation for Liverpool’s press. The double pivot’s discipline becomes non-negotiable, because the counter-pressing trigger that Haaland usually provides — the first chase, the forced error — disappears with him. Maresca would need his wingers to defend like full-backs and his full-backs to attack like wingers, all while keeping the defensive line high enough to compress the space Liverpool love to run into.

And there is a psychological layer too. For years, opponents have prepared for City by preparing for Haaland — our earlier tactical-fit analysis of Haaland in Arteta’s 4-3-3 showed how even Arsenal’s interest was framed around the Norwegian’s gravitational pull. Take him out of the team sheet and Liverpool’s centre-backs suddenly face a puzzle instead of a person. Sometimes the unknown is harder to defend than the inevitable.

Verdict: The Machine Was Built for This

Solbakken’s confession should calm the panic: the most likely reading is that a carefully managed 65 minutes, not a torn muscle, is the whole story, and Haaland will lead the line at Anfield. But the ten minutes of terror in Porto served a purpose — they forced everyone to confront the question City’s rivals have been avoiding all season. What happens when the Viking is not there?

The answer, on paper, is reassuring for the champions. The system predates the striker and will outlast him. A false-nine 4-2-4 with Semenyo dropping, Fernandez arriving, and the wingers flooding the half-spaces is not a patched-up emergency plan; it is a legitimate elite attacking structure, the same one that won City titles before Haaland ever arrived. The real cost is not tactical but psychological — the aura of inevitability that walks onto the pitch with the No.9 on his back.

Anfield will give us the answer. If Haaland starts and scores, Porto becomes a masterclass in load management. If he does not, we find out whether Maresca’s machine can hum without its loudest instrument. Either way, the blueprint exists — and after Sunday night, everyone knows it.

James Whitfield is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactics, transfers and the stories behind the results.