Liverpool came from 2-0 down to beat Villarreal 4-3 at Anfield in the Champions League, and Alexis Mac Allister is our top-rated player with a 9 after scoring twice.

Villarreal were ahead after four minutes, when Georges Mikautadze scored after a Virgil van Dijk error, and Sergi Cardona made it 2-0 on 29. Mac Allister headed in from a Kostas Tsimikas corner on 36 and Ronald Araujo levelled in first-half added time. Mac Allister put Liverpool in front on 65 and Florian Wirtz scored three minutes later. Tani Oluwaseyi pulled one back on 87, but Liverpool held on. Goal times follow the Sky Sports match report.

Liverpool player ratings

These are our ratings, based on what happened on the pitch. Where we have no detail on a player, we’ve kept the reason general. Substitutes who came on after the 70th minute aren’t rated.

Player Position Rating Reason
Alexis Mac Allister Midfielder 9 (top) Scored twice: a header from a corner before the break and the 3-2 from Ngumoha’s cut-back.
Florian Wirtz Substitute (46′) 8 On at half-time and scored the fourth on 68 minutes.
Ronald Araujo Defender 7 Equalised in first-half added time, then made way for Wirtz at the restart.
Rio Ngumoha Winger 7 Crossed for Araujo’s equaliser, then beat Cardona and cut back for Mac Allister’s 3-2.
Cody Gakpo Forward 7 Mouriño was booked for a foul on him before the break.
Alisson Goalkeeper 6 Three conceded, but nothing in the sources puts any of them on him.
Ryan Gravenberch Midfielder 6 Steady, little to note in the sources.
Jeremy Jacquet Defender 6 Steady, little to note in the sources. Off on 74′.
Konstantinos Tsimikas Defender 7 Delivered the corner for Mac Allister’s first goal.
Trey Nyoni Midfielder 6 Steady, little to note in the sources. Off on 81′.
Lewis Koumas Forward 6 Little to note in the sources. Off on 66′.
Alexander Isak Forward (sub, 66′) 6 On for Koumas on 66′. No standout moment in the sources.
Virgil van Dijk Defender 5 (lowest) His error led to Mikautadze’s opener after four minutes.
Joe Gomez, Bradley Barcola, James McConnell Subs (74′, 74′, 81′) N/A Too little time to rate.

Mac Allister over Wirtz

An 8 for a half-time substitute who scored on 68 minutes is fair, and some will say Wirtz’s goal made it 4-2 and sealed it. We’d still pick Mac Allister. He pulled Liverpool back into the game before the break, and his second put them in front for the first time.

Van Dijk gets the lowest mark. The opener came from his mistake, and it left Liverpool chasing from the fourth minute. The side conceded three at home, but his is the error you can point to. The lack of detail in the sources is why so many defenders sit on a 6.

Araujo’s goal and his exit are the odd part. He scored in added time, then was replaced at the restart. The sources give no reason, so we haven’t guessed one.

For more on the line-up, see our predicted XI and the injury news before kick-off, and our Rio Ngumoha scouting report. Here are the Brentford player ratings from Saturday’s 2-1 win.

Liverpool host Brighton on Sunday 25 October, kick-off 14:00 UK time.

Was Mac Allister or Wirtz Liverpool’s real match-winner against Villarreal? Give us your ratings below.

Featured photo: Bryan Berlin, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).

Arjun Rao is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactical breakdowns, transfer analysis and the numbers behind the game.