Juventus are already preparing for life after Nick Woltemade. La Gazzetta dello Sport reports that the Turin club have started lining up alternatives to the German striker only weeks into his season-long loan from Newcastle United, after one goal in four appearances and a two-yard miss for Germany against Serbia that travelled around the world during the international break.

Juventus striker search board showing Nick Woltemade's record of one goal in four games and the three reported alternatives: Mateo Retegui, Folarin Balogun and Antonio Raimondo

The miss that changed everything

With half an hour left in Munich, Germany leading Serbia, Woltemade met the ball two yards out with the goal gaping and sent it over the crossbar. The clip went viral, the German press turned on him, and according to Gazzetta it deepened concerns that were already forming in Turin. Luciano Spalletti had hoped the international break, under Germany’s new coach Jurgen Klopp, would send his striker back rejuvenated. Instead Woltemade barely played and didn’t score. One goal in four Juventus appearances is a poor return for a player signed to provide goals, and the timing of the miss couldn’t have been worse. The first doubts had already been flagged in Friday’s gossip roundup; Gazzetta has now put detail behind them.

The wrong profile for the job

At 1.98m, Woltemade looks like one. He doesn’t play like one. By his own admission, aerial duels aren’t his strength; he prefers to drop deep and link play as a second striker. Gazzetta’s analysis is blunt: Juventus already have plenty of players who operate in those zones. Kenan Yildiz is working his way back from injury, Kerim Alajbegovic can play behind the striker, Nico Gonzalez has filled that role under Spalletti and Weston McKennie drifts into it by instinct. What Juventus lack is the pure penalty-box forward, the player who lives between the centre-backs. Woltemade has said himself he isn’t that player. There were warning signs before the break, too: his clumsiness in the 3-2 defeat at Sassuolo on 13 September had already caused unease. Randal Kolo Muani, signed permanently in the summer, has also struggled, which only sharpens the problem.

Three names on the list

According to Gazzetta, the club are weighing three options for the No. 9 role. Mateo Retegui, the former Atalanta striker now at Al-Qadsiah in Saudi Arabia. Antonio Raimondo, who has four league goals this season on loan at Frosinone from Bologna. And Folarin Balogun, the former Arsenal forward now at Monaco. The paper stresses there are no advanced negotiations yet, but the direction of travel is clear.

Balogun is the most interesting name. The 25-year-old United States international has 31 goals and 13 assists in 92 appearances for Monaco, and his proposed £38.5m move to Everton collapsed on summer deadline day after he completed his medical and then walked away, as we detailed at the time. Arsenal, who sold him in 2023, inserted a 17.5% sell-on clause into the deal, so any January move would send money back to north London, as football.london reports.

What it means for Newcastle

This is a straight loan: a £3.5m fee, no purchase option and no mechanism for Juventus to keep him. He returns to Newcastle in June 2027, and on current evidence he will return with his value lower than when he left. Newcastle signed Woltemade from Stuttgart, where he scored 12 goals, to replace Alexander Isak after the Swede forced through his move to Liverpool in the summer of 2025. He started with four goals in his first five Premier League games, then faded down the pecking order under Eddie Howe. The loan was supposed to rebuild rhythm and reputation. He has seven months to turn it around, and right now it’s going the wrong way.

Sunday in Cagliari cannot wait

The January window is months away; Sunday isn’t. Juventus travel to Cagliari this weekend needing goals from somewhere, and there’s at least one boost: Kerim Alajbegovic has been cleared by the club’s medical staff after a scare on duty with Bosnia and is expected to start, according to Sky Sport Italia. The predicted side has Guglielmo Vicario in goal; Pierre Kalulu, Bremer, Lloyd Kelly and Andrea Cambiaso in defence; Douglas Luiz and Pape Matar Sarr in midfield; and Edon Zhegrova, Weston McKennie and Alajbegovic behind Kolo Muani. It isn’t the only January decision facing the club either: Teun Koopmeiners’ future in Turin is also uncertain.

Kabir Anand covers the Premier League for The False 9 — match analysis, emerging talent and the stories shaping English football.