Roberto Mancini made three substitutions in the 55th minute against Türkiye with the score at 1-0, and nine minutes later two of those substitutes had combined to put Italy 2-1 up and on course for a 3-1 win that moved the Azzurri second in Nations League Group A1. It was the boldest in-game decision of Mancini’s second spell, and it turned an anxious night at the Stadio Renato Dall’Ara into further evidence that this rebuilt Italy can win when not at their best. Here is how the bench decided the game in Bologna.
- Scamacca’s 26th-Minute Opener: Patience Behind Italy’s 4-3-3
- The 55th-Minute Triple Substitution That Won the Game
- Calafiori and Pio Esposito: Two Substitutes, Two Goals
- Donnarumma’s Decisive Saves: The Wall Behind the Revival
- Group A1 Standings: What Second Place Means for November
- Mancini’s System Taking Shape: Three Unbeaten and Counting
Scamacca’s 26th-Minute Opener: Patience Behind Italy’s 4-3-3
For 25 minutes in Bologna, Italy’s 4-3-3 looked like a team thinking its way through a problem rather than overpowering it. Vincenzo Montella’s Türkiye arrived in a compact 5-3-2, held 55% of the ball in the first half and even created the clearer early openings: Gianluigi Donnarumma had to beat away a fierce Özcan strike in the 17th minute, and Aral Şimşir nearly rounded the Paris Saint-Germain goalkeeper before Donnarumma recovered. Italy, by contrast, bided their time.
The breakthrough, when it came, was a product of structure rather than inspiration. Antonio Vergara fed Giovanni Di Lorenzo on the right wing, and the full-back’s lifted cross found Gianluca Scamacca attacking the space between Abdülkerim Bardakcı and Ozan Kabak. The Atalanta striker’s initial header was blocked, but he lashed the rebound home with a powerful strike in the 26th minute. It was, according to the FIGC’s official match report, a reward for Italy’s right-sided overload: Di Lorenzo and Vergara repeatedly doubled up on Eren Elmalı, stretching Türkiye’s back five until the gaps appeared.
Behind the front three, the midfield trio told its own story. Alessandro Romano sat deepest as the single pivot, Nicolò Barella shuttled between the lines, and Issa Doumbia provided the vertical thrust. It is a midfield built for control, and for long spells of the first half Italy had it, even without the ball. Türkiye had plenty of possession in front of Italy’s block but almost none behind it.
The 55th-Minute Triple Substitution That Won the Game
Mancini’s key decision came ten minutes after the restart. With Italy leading 1-0 but losing momentum, as Türkiye started the second half on the front foot, he withdrew Di Lorenzo, Matteo Ruggeri and Scamacca in one sweeping triple change. On came Michael Kayode, the Brentford full-back tracked by Juventus, Riccardo Calafiori and Francesco Pio Esposito.
The logic was threefold. Kayode’s athleticism gave Italy a more aggressive right-back to pin back Elmalı. Calafiori’s left-footed presence at left-back added a new diagonal passing lane into Barella’s zone. And Esposito’s fresh legs gave the press a new trigger at the head of the 4-3-3. Within five minutes, though, the plan looked like it had backfired: in the 60th minute, Zeki Çelik’s cross was flicked on by Elmalı at the near post, and Şimşir swept home left-footed at the far post to make it 1-1. The Dall’Ara fell silent. Mancini’s gamble appeared to have destabilised the very structure that had earned the lead.
The changes worked. Italy did not sit back. Barella immediately took ownership of the tempo, Romano dropped five yards deeper to protect the centre-backs, and the wingers tucked in to create a 4-5-1 out of possession that stopped Türkiye building on the equaliser. The response came from the bench.
Calafiori and Pio Esposito: Two Substitutes, Two Goals
Four minutes after conceding, Italy were ahead again through the substitutes. Barella’s well-placed free-kick from the left channel hung over the penalty spot, and Calafiori rose above Elmalı at the back post to head home his first international goal in the 64th minute. The Arsenal defender’s timing was excellent: he started his run as Barella struck the ball, beating a Turkish marking scheme that was zonal at the near post and man-to-man at the far post.
The third goal, in the 88th minute, was the best team move of the night. Donnarumma claimed a Türkiye corner, and Italy broke quickly: Doumbia burst down the right and delivered a low cross, Romano fired first time, and Pio Esposito finished at close range. The Inter youngster’s first senior international goal sealed a 3-1 win in front of a 30,040 crowd, on the night Bologna celebrated the club’s 117th anniversary at the Dall’Ara.
Two substitutes combined for a goal within nine minutes of the triple change, and another sub scored the third. Mancini read the game well, and his replacements decided it.
Donnarumma’s Decisive Saves: The Wall Behind the Revival
No analysis of this Italy is complete without Donnarumma. Long before the substitutes took centre stage, the captain kept the Azzurri in the game with three decisive interventions: the 17th-minute denial of Özcan, the recovery after Şimşir rounded him, and a late parry from another Özcan drive as Türkiye chased a second equaliser at 2-1. Each save came at a moment when the momentum was tilting Turkish; each one bought Mancini’s side the time to find their response.
There is a broader point here about Italy’s defensive structure. The back four of Di Lorenzo, Gianluca Mancini, Alessandro Bastoni and Ruggeri (later Kayode and Calafiori) conceded possession but rarely conceded space. Türkiye’s 55% of the ball produced only a handful of real chances, and two of those required Donnarumma at his best. This is the trade-off Mancini has accepted: less control of the ball, more control of the territory that matters. Against a Türkiye side that had scored in every Nations League game this season, it was enough.
Group A1 Standings: What Second Place Means for November
The 3-1 win moved Italy to 7 points and second place in Group A1: France lead on 10 after their 4-1 comeback win over Belgium in Saint-Denis, Belgium sit third on 6, and Türkiye are bottom without a point after four straight defeats, as Reuters reported. Italy are now guaranteed to finish at least third in the group, a good outcome for a side that began this campaign with a 2-0 home defeat to Belgium.

November is now a key month for Mancini’s rebuild. Italy host France on 12 November and travel to Belgium on 15 November, two fixtures that will decide the quarter-final race. Beat France in the return, and Italy could yet top the group; take four points from the two games, and a top-two finish is in their hands. The concern is personnel: Vergara left the field in the 83rd minute with a calf injury that will worry Napoli, while Scamacca and Ruggeri both went into the book in Bologna and are at risk of suspension.
Mancini’s System Taking Shape: Three Unbeaten and Counting
The overall trend is positive. Since the 2-0 defeat to Belgium on 25 September, Italy have won 4-1 in Türkiye, drawn 1-1 away to France (as covered in our five talking points from Paris) and now beaten Türkiye 3-1 at home. Three games unbeaten, seven points from nine, and a clearer tactical identity since that September low.
That identity is pragmatic: A 4-3-3 that defends in a compact mid-block, full-backs who overlap in carefully chosen moments rather than by default, a single pivot in Romano who recycles rather than risks, and a bench that Mancini trusts to change games, as it did in Bologna. The triple substitution was not a panic move but part of the plan, with Kayode, Calafiori and Esposito each briefed to attack a specific Turkish weakness.
There are still questions. Italy’s 45% possession at home to the group’s bottom side will concern some, and the reliance on Donnarumma is becoming a pattern. But international managers are judged on results, and Mancini is getting them. From the Belgium defeat to second place and a November decider with France, the improvement is real.







Discussion
What is your take? Join the discussion below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.