Mikel Arteta has a striker decision to make, and The Times believes it’s the most delicate of his season so far. With Kai Havertz nursing the hamstring injury he suffered on international duty with Germany, Arsenal’s manager must choose who leads the line against Leeds United at the Emirates on Saturday (12.30pm): Viktor Gyokeres, goalless in five club games, or Mikel Merino, the midfielder turned emergency forward who can’t stop scoring for Spain.
In this article

The Times, in an analysis published on Friday morning, framed it as a straight choice between the pair, the first time Arteta has had that option since Havertz returned from nearly a year out in January. Havertz may yet recover in time to face Leeds, but as the paper notes, his minutes will need careful management either way. That leaves the Sweden striker against the Spain midfielder, and both arrive in very different form.
The case for Gyokeres
On international duty, Gyokeres looks like a different player. He scored in each of Sweden’s four Nations League matches in this break, three poacher’s finishes plus a driven strike against Bosnia-Herzegovina after collecting a through ball. It extended his run to seven consecutive Nations League scoring appearances, a competition record.
Arsenal legend Alan Smith, speaking to Gooner News this week, backed the 28-year-old to “get the nod”, arguing that four goals in four games for his country should send him back to London Colney with his confidence restored after a difficult start. Gyokeres has played only 29 league minutes off the bench this season and is yet to score for the club, so Saturday would be his first Premier League start of the campaign.
There’s also history on his side. Gyokeres opened his Arsenal account in the 5-0 win at home to Leeds last season, collecting a ball over the top, cutting inside and finishing at the near post, and he scored again in the 3-0 win in the reverse fixture in January. The numbers back him too: his nine league goals as a striker have arrived every 161 minutes, compared with one every 214 for Merino since the Spaniard first started up front in February 2025.
The case for Merino
Merino’s case is built on something harder to measure: timing. He struck three goals for Spain during the break and has been hailed in the Spanish press as the team’s “official rescuer” for his habit of settling matches in their favour. Two of those goals came in the 2-1 comeback win over Croatia on Tuesday, a calm side-footed equaliser followed by a controlled turn and finish for the winner four minutes from time.
The nickname dates back further. Merino scored decisive late goals against Portugal and Belgium on Spain’s run to winning the World Cup in the summer, and his movement dragged defenders away to create the space for Ferran Torres to score the winner against Argentina in the final. Spain coach Luis de la Fuente said this week: “He has that gift that is the sense of the goal, for important goals. He knows how to understand these moments.”
Tactically, Merino is closer to Havertz. The Times notes his style as a forward is more similar to the German than Gyokeres is, which matters for a side built around fluid movement and positional interchange. It’s only 20 months since Merino was first asked to play as an emergency striker in his career, yet he ended last season with 17 goals, six for Arsenal and 11 for Spain, and ten of his eleven league goals for the club either put Arsenal ahead or levelled the score. His glancing header to level away at Newcastle was arguably one of the most important goals of last season.
The doubts on both sides
Neither option is clean. The most pointed criticism of Gyokeres came from Teddy Sheringham, who told the Swedish outlet Hajper: “It shocks me that he is still playing like a kid. I don’t think he has understood what it means to be an attacking player and what he has to do. There are different ways to play striker, but he needs to be told to hold on to the ball.”
The Times’ analysis supports parts of that argument. Gyokeres’s technical shortcomings have hindered the fluidity of Arsenal’s play, he was a mixed bag trying to retain possession after coming on in the 2-1 win over Chelsea last month, and the theory that he can at least punish weaker sides wasn’t supported when he struggled against a weakened Ipswich in the Carabao Cup. He is at his best running onto the ball and attacking space on the counter, which isn’t how most teams defend at the Emirates. There’s also a caveat on the Sweden goals: of the six opponents in his scoring run, only Poland are ranked in the world’s top 50, and he never scored against a side that finished in the top five last season despite hitting 21 goals across all competitions.
Merino’s limitations are physical. He was substituted at half-time after one of his poorest performances in the 2-1 defeat by Aston Villa in December, and he doesn’t have the speed to stretch opponents, which changes how Arsenal can attack. Leeds, unbeaten and fifth after five games, defend in a compact 3-5-2 that may not offer the space a slower forward needs.
Gyokeres himself addressed the noise after Sweden’s win over Romania two weeks ago. “Either they criticise you or you get positive criticism,” he said. “If it comes a lot and if you read it, of course you can be influenced. But that’s not something I do. That’s how it goes for all footballers, ups and downs.”
What Arteta is weighing
There’s also the psychological side. The Times suggests Arteta must consider whether it would damage Gyokeres to be overlooked for a makeshift striker in Merino, a midfielder asked to do a job he never trained for. Dropping the club’s specialist No. 9 for a converted midfielder, days after the Swede scored four in four for his country, would be a public statement about trust.
We think it comes down to what Arteta wants against a low block. Leeds will come to the Emirates to frustrate, as we noted in our pre-break look at his selection calls, and Merino’s movement between the lines, honed over 20 months of emergency service, is the more reliable tool for unpicking a compact defence. Gyokeres offers the penalty-box instinct and a superior minutes-per-goal record, but his hold-up play remains the concern Sheringham identified.
With Christos Tzolis sidelined for two to three weeks and Havertz’s minutes needing management, Arteta is short of alternatives, which makes getting this call right even more important. We’ll know when the teams come out at 11.30am on Saturday. Either way, the debate won’t go away until Arsenal sign the more clinical forward this squad still lacks.






Discussion
What is your take? Join the discussion below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.