Aston Villa will consider backing out of their deal to sign Alejandro Garnacho on a permanent basis if the winger’s form does not improve, according to BBC Sport’s gossip column, which carries a report from Football Insider published on Friday 23 October. The 22-year-old Argentine joined Villa on a season-long loan from Chelsea in the summer, in a deal reported at around £43m if an appearance-based purchase obligation is triggered. So far he has played 31 minutes of football under Unai Emery.
In this article
31 minutes and no starts
Football Insider reports that Villa have already decided, as things stand, to avoid playing Garnacho enough to trigger the buy clause in the loan, and that Emery is prepared to leave him out if his form does not improve. Garnacho has not started a match for Villa, his league involvement amounts to a handful of substitute appearances, and his total across the season is the 31 minutes Football Insider cites.
That is a sharp drop for a player who recorded 12 goal involvements for Chelsea in all competitions last season. Villa signed him to add a direct wide option on the left, a player who carries the ball at full backs and attacks the far post when the ball is on the opposite side. None of that has been seen in a Villa shirt yet, because he has barely been on the pitch.

Why Emery has not used him
Emery’s wide players have two jobs. With the ball they hold the width so Villa’s midfielders can play between the lines. Without it they drop in to form a compact second line and press from there, and a winger who switches off leaves the full back behind him exposed to an overlap. The players currently holding the wide places have done that work across a demanding start, and our look at Emery’s predicted lineup against Man City has Emiliano Buendia keeping his place for Saturday’s game at Villa Park.
Garnacho has had moments to build on and has not built on them. Football Insider notes that he scored in a friendly against Sevilla, but has played just 11 minutes in the Champions League since then, and he was not part of the group that travelled to Newcastle last weekend, when Villa won 1-0 at St James’ Park. A loan player who is not in the travelling squad in October is not close to the team, whatever his reputation.
The Elliott precedent and the profit option
Villa have been in this position before, and recently. Football Insider points out that the club played out a similar scenario with Harvey Elliott last season, when they were determined to avoid triggering their buy option for the Liverpool midfielder and managed his appearances accordingly. An appearance-based obligation cuts both ways: it protects the buying club if the player does not settle, but it also gives the club a reason to hold a player back once they have made up their minds.
There is one other route in the report. Former Villa chief executive Keith Wyness has told Football Insider that the club could trigger the purchase clause and then try to sell Garnacho on for a profit straight away, arguing that his reputation would still attract interest from European clubs. That route also depends on the player’s form recovering, because a winger with 31 minutes by late October is not appreciating in value on the bench.
Chelsea’s position adds to the pressure on the player. Football Insider reports that he has no long-term future at Stamford Bridge, so a return next summer leaves him looking for another move, two seasons after joining Chelsea from Manchester United. Chelsea are fourth in the Premier League and play Tottenham at home on Saturday evening, a game covered in our team news on James Maddison’s fitness doubt, and their attack has moved on without him.
What happens next
Villa are 12th in the Premier League with eight points from seven games, and they host league leaders Manchester City at Villa Park on Saturday 24 October, kick-off 12.30pm. Garnacho’s immediate task is narrower than the fixture list. He has to convince Emery in training that he can be trusted with the defensive side of the wide role, because the ability on the ball has never been the question.
If the minutes do not come over the next two months, the appearance threshold in the loan will settle the matter on its own, and Villa will send him back to Chelsea at the end of the season without paying the fee.







Discussion
Good move or not? Have your say below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.