Jake O’Brien is set for his first Premier League start of the season when Everton visit Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium on Saturday 24 October (15:00), with David Moyes expected to drop Ainsley Maitland-Niles after the right-back was taken off 55 minutes into the 2-0 home defeat by Chelsea.

The predicted XI

Everton go to north London eighth in the Premier League with 10 points from seven games, two wins, four draws and one defeat. That defeat came on Saturday, when Pedro Neto scored twice in the second half for Chelsea at Hill Dickinson Stadium. Moyes is not a manager who changes a side after one loss, and the shape stays 4-2-3-1. The one change is at right-back, where the opponent and the evidence from the last two games both point the same way.

Everton predicted XI (4-2-3-1)

Barry

Grealish

Dewsbury-Hall

Rohl

Garner

Armstrong

Mykolenko

Branthwaite

Tarkowski

O’Brien

Pickford

Why O’Brien, and why now

Maitland-Niles has had a difficult fortnight in the position. At Hull City he made mistakes for both home goals in the 2-2 draw, and against Chelsea the opening goal came down his side, with Jorrel Hato overlapping into the box too easily. His numbers in that game were one duel won from seven, 15 passes completed from 20, and possession lost 10 times, and Moyes replaced him after 55 minutes, with Merlin Rohl moving back to right-back and Tyrique George coming on.

O’Brien is the opposite profile. At 6ft 6in he gives Everton a third tall defender at set pieces, in a game against the side most associated with scoring from them, and he defends the far post in a way a converted midfielder does not. He has made three substitute appearances in the league this season and no starts, so this would be a first start picked for a specific opponent rather than a run of form. Moyes has kept his public line simple, saying recently: “He’s an important member of the squad, but he’s going to have to wait his turn and wait and see when the opportunity comes up for him.” Arsenal away, up against Madueke or Eze on that flank, is the sort of opportunity that line points to.

Team news

The rest of the side is the one that started against Chelsea. Jordan Pickford is in goal, James Tarkowski and Jarrad Branthwaite stay together in the middle, and Vitalii Mykolenko is expected to start at left-back after returning for the Chelsea game. He is the one name to watch in the fitness listings this week, but he started on Saturday and there’s no fresh absence reported for him.

James Garner and Harrison Armstrong keep the two holding places. Armstrong’s running has made him hard to leave out, and Garner takes the set pieces from deep. Ahead of them, Rohl starts on the right, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall in the middle and Jack Grealish on the left, with Thierno Barry leading the line. Barry is Everton’s top scorer this season with three league goals. The options from the bench include Tyler Dibling, Brennan Johnson, Carlos Alcaraz and Hayden Hackney, all of whom were among the substitutes against Chelsea. How that bench was used last week is part of our player ratings from the Chelsea defeat.

Everton at Arsenal team news board: Everton eighth on 10 points, O'Brien set to replace Maitland-Niles at right-back

How Everton will set up

Everton will not have the ball for long spells, and the plan has to work without it. Arsenal had 74% possession at Nottingham Forest on Sunday and still needed until the 80th minute, and their only shot on target, to score through Noni Madueke. That game, covered in our Forest v Arsenal player ratings, is the template Moyes will study: a compact block, no space between the lines for Martin Odegaard, and the wide players tracking the full-backs rather than waiting high.

The double pivot is the mechanism that makes it work. Garner screens the pass into Odegaard and Armstrong goes with Declan Rice when Rice carries forward, so Arsenal’s two most-used routes into the final third are both met by a midfielder rather than a defender stepping out. If a centre-back steps out, the back line becomes a three against Saka, Madueke or Eze and Viktor Gyokeres, and that’s where Forest eventually cracked. Everton’s own route forward is narrower: Grealish holding the ball on the left to win fouls and move the team up the pitch, Barry pinning the centre-backs, and set pieces taken by Garner and Dewsbury-Hall into a box that now includes O’Brien, Tarkowski and Branthwaite.

There’s also a scheduling point in Everton’s favour. Arsenal play at Bayern Munich in the Champions League on Wednesday night, three days before this game, a trip we set out in our Arsenal lineup piece for the Forest game as the start of a heavy week. Everton have the full week to prepare. A side that defends in a block needs its distances right more than it needs fresh legs, but a full week of training on one opponent is still an advantage Moyes rarely gets in this part of the season.

The lineup in full

Everton (4-2-3-1): Pickford; O’Brien, Tarkowski, Branthwaite, Mykolenko; Garner, Armstrong; Rohl, Dewsbury-Hall, Grealish; Barry.

Arsenal v Everton kicks off at 15:00 on Saturday 24 October at the Emirates Stadium, with the confirmed teams announced an hour before.

Luca Marchetti is a football writer covering Serie A and European football, specialising in tactical analysis and the transfer market.