Vitalii Mykolenko has played every single minute of Everton’s season — and now David Moyes might have to do without him. Sent home early from Ukraine duty with an unspecified injury, the left-back is a doubt for the trip to Hull City, leaving Moyes with no senior back-up and a defensive dilemma. Here are the five talking points defining Everton’s international break.
The Mykolenko blow: Everton’s ever-present sent home
Vitalii Mykolenko has started all seven of Everton’s matches this season in all competitions — every minute, every game, the definition of undroppable. So when Ukraine’s FA released a statement on Thursday night confirming the 27-year-old would play no further part in their Nations League fixtures and was returning to Finch Farm for rehabilitation, as reported by Goodison News, alarm bells rang on Merseyside.
The timeline is worrying. Mykolenko played the full 90 minutes of Ukraine’s 1-0 win in Hungary, then missed the goalless draw with Georgia on Monday. Ukraine manager Andrea Maldera confirmed the defender would also sit out the clash with Northern Ireland: “We still cannot count on Mykolenko, unfortunately. He is not feeling very well, we respect him and do not want him to get injured more seriously.” That update, published on October 1, leaves the nature of the problem unclear — muscle issue, illness, or both — but the consequence is the same: Moyes is sweating on his most reliable defender.
The knock is not believed to be serious, per TEAMtalk via LiveScore, but with no prognosis confirmed, his availability for the Hull trip is genuinely in doubt. For a player who has been one of Everton’s best performers this season, that is a blow Moyes could do without.
Consider what would be missing. Mykolenko’s consistency has underpinned Everton’s defensive solidity — just three goals conceded in five league games, the joint-best defensive record among the top-half sides. He is not a marauding modern full-back; he is something rarer in this Everton side: a defender Moyes trusts completely, positionally sound, rarely beaten one-on-one, and relentless in the duel. Replacing that reliability with an improvisation is the single biggest risk to the unbeaten run.
The left-back dilemma: who fills the void at Hull?
Here is the uncomfortable truth: Mykolenko is Everton’s only natural left-back. Adam Aznou was sent out on loan to Malaga for the season, and the failure to add depth in the summer is already coming back to haunt the Toffees’ ambitions. If Mykolenko does not make Hull, Moyes must improvise — and his options each carry a compromise.
Ainsley Maitland-Niles is the most natural fit, having played left-back before, and could slot in with minimal disruption. James Garner is another candidate — he filled in at left-back three times last season, contributing an assist in the win over Brighton — but Moyes will be reluctant to move him from a midfield role in which he is thriving. The more radical solutions involve shifting Jake O’Brien across from the right or even deploying Jarrad Branthwaite out of position, either of which would weaken two positions to fix one. As we explored in our tactical breakdown of the £25m battle for Crystal Palace’s Tyrick Mitchell, elite left-backs are gold dust — and Everton’s lack of one behind Mykolenko is a squad-planning failure.
Moyes’ instinct will be to keep disruption minimal: Maitland-Niles at left-back, O’Brien continuing on the right, Branthwaite and Tarkowski undisturbed in the middle. But against an in-form Hull side, any makeshift full-back will be targeted. This is the kind of selection headache that decides tight away games.
And Hull will smell blood. The Tigers sit eighth and have made a habit of attacking the channels, and any opposition analyst worth their salt will have circled Everton’s left flank the moment Mykolenko boarded his flight home. A makeshift left-back against pacy wide players is the oldest mismatch in football — Moyes knows it, Hull’s manager knows it, and the first twenty minutes at the MKM Stadium will tell us whether Everton’s defensive structure can protect whoever fills in.

Norgaard’s return: the £7m man finally emerges
There is better news in midfield. Christian Norgaard, the £7 million summer signing from Arsenal, was pictured in group training at Finch Farm this week — his first tangible step toward an Everton debut after a groin injury ruined his start on Merseyside. Moyes has admitted the recovery took longer than expected, but the Denmark international is now closing in on involvement.
“We’re hoping we get him back somewhere after the international break,” Moyes said. “He’s hugely important for us. He’s someone who we’re looking forward to gaining his experience, his nous.” Norgaard brings exactly what Everton’s midfield needs: positional discipline, Premier League title-winning experience from north London, and the ability to shield a back four. With Merlin Rohl also believed to be back in contention, Moyes could suddenly have options in the engine room.
The smart move is patience — easing Norgaard back rather than throwing him in at Hull — but his return transforms the squad’s depth. Everton’s thin squad was always one injury crisis away from trouble; getting bodies back is as important as any tactical tweak.
Tactically, Norgaard changes what Moyes can do. The Dane is a specialist screener — the kind of midfielder who holds his position, recycles possession and lets the more adventurous players ahead of him take risks. In a side built on defensive solidity first, that profile is gold: it frees James Garner to push higher, gives the full-backs cover to overlap, and adds a calm head in the game’s ugliest moments. Everton didn’t pay £7 million for highlight reels; they paid for the invisible work that turns draws into wins.
The Nsangou question: from Blackburn to the Hull squad?
And then there is the wildcard. Sixteen-year-old Jonathan Nsangou announced himself with a late equaliser in the behind-closed-doors 3-3 draw with Blackburn, and the clamour for his involvement is growing. As we detailed in our wonderkid profile, the Poland-born striker has 10 goals in 27 U18 appearances and a Ballon d’Or dream — and with Everton’s senior striker options thin, the Hull trip might be the perfect low-pressure debut.
Moyes has always been willing to trust youth when the moment is right, and a bench spot at Hull would be a statement of intent without throwing the teenager into the fire. With Thierno Barry the lone senior striker and goals spread thinly, Nsangou’s movement and finishing could offer something different late in games. Don’t be surprised if his name is in the travelling squad.

The Hull litmus test: joint-fourth and the unbeaten run
Step back and admire the bigger picture: Everton are unbeaten across all competitions, with nine points from their opening five Premier League games — good enough for joint-fourth. For a club that has spent recent seasons flirting with relegation, this is uncharted territory. The 1-0 win over Ipswich before the break was the latest evidence of a side that is hard to beat and growing in belief.
Hull away is the litmus test. The Tigers are in-form and sitting eighth, and this is exactly the kind of fixture where good seasons are built — or where unbeaten runs die carelessly. Moyes will demand professionalism, compactness and ruthlessness. With Mykolenko potentially missing, Norgaard edging back and Nsangou knocking on the door, it is a squad being tested in real time.
Zoom out further and the transformation is remarkable. This is a club that spent the last five seasons finishing 13th, 13th, 15th, 17th and 16th — a club defined by relegation scraps and Goodison farewells. Now, in the Hill Dickinson Stadium era, Moyes has built the league’s meanest defences and a side that expects to win. The international break could have derailed that momentum; instead, the returning cavalry of Norgaard and Rohl, plus the emergence of Nsangou, suggests the squad is actually getting stronger.
There is one more subplot: Jordan Pickford’s England demotion. Thomas Tuchel handed James Trafford the gloves for England’s recent fixtures, leaving Pickford watching from the bench — unfamiliar territory for the Three Lions’ long-standing No.1. A commanding performance at Hull would be the perfect response. For Everton, for Moyes and for England’s benched goalkeeper, October 11 matters more than it looks.







Discussion
What is your take? Join the discussion below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.