Stoke City won 1-0 at Derby County on Saturday through Luke Graham’s header four minutes into the second half, and the tactical story of the afternoon at Pride Park was a familiar one for the home side: Derby had more of the ball, more shots and the later pressure, but Stoke’s back three, a set piece and Viktor Johansson’s late save were worth more than any of it.

Derby 0-1 Stoke tactical board: Stoke back three, Graham header and Johansson save

Possession without a route through Stoke’s back three

Derby set up in a 4-2-3-1, with Lewis Travis and David Ozoh at the base of midfield, Sammie Szmodics, Bobby Clark and Mohammed Fuseini behind Carlton Morris. Stoke matched the numbers in midfield with a 3-4-2-1: Ben Wilmot, Bosun Lawal and Graham across the back, Jack McGlynn and Justin Devenny tucked in behind Lamine Cisse, and Ethan Galbraith and El Hadji Soumare holding the centre.

That shape gave Stoke a spare man at the back whenever Morris pressed, and it showed in the pattern of the first half. Derby finished the match with 53 per cent of the ball, according to the match data, but Morris was left to fight Wilmot and Lawal with few runners going beyond him, and the home side’s best opening of the half came from a corner that fell to Szmodics, whose goalbound shot was blocked. Stoke, for their part, had the first chance when Cisse broke forward and found McGlynn, whose low shot did not trouble Josh Vickers.

The one moment of first-half controversy followed the same pattern. Morris got away from Lawal, appeared to be tripped, and referee Oliver Langford waved the penalty appeals away. Derby had the territory but not the openings, a problem Norwich found from the other side in their 1-0 defeat by Portsmouth on the same afternoon.

The set piece that changed both shapes

Stoke lost Eric Bocat to injury before the break, with Luca Bombino on in his place at left wing-back, and George Hirst replaced McGlynn at half-time. Four minutes later the game changed. Galbraith delivered a free-kick and Graham, the left-sided centre-back, met it with a header that Vickers got a hand to before the ball went in off his left post. It was Graham’s first goal for Stoke.

A goal from a centre-back at a set piece was a fair summary of where the threat had come from all afternoon. Neither side had built a clear chance through the middle in open play, because both midfields were set up to protect that space. Once Stoke led, the shapes flipped: Derby had to push their full-backs on and commit the wide players, and Stoke could defend the box with numbers and break into the space left behind.

Eustace’s change and Derby’s wide push

John Eustace responded within three minutes of the goal, sending on Rhian Brewster for Travis. That changed Derby’s structure: Ozoh was left as the single holder, Szmodics and Clark played higher, and Derby’s attacks went wide earlier, with Joe Ward and Ryan Hedges asked to deliver from the flanks rather than work the ball through the centre.

It produced Derby’s best spell. Brewster went close from the edge of the area in the 63rd minute, Ozoh beat Lawal and saw a shot blocked after hesitating, and the home side ended with 17 shots to Stoke’s 12, though only three were on target. The width created volume, but Stoke’s three centre-backs were defending crosses from in front of the penalty spot rather than being turned, and Morris rarely got a run at a delivery without Wilmot or Lawal in contact with him.

Stoke’s back five and the Johansson save

Mark Robins protected the lead in layers. Maksym Talovierov replaced Lawal in the 68th minute, adding height to the back line, and Robert Bozenik came on for Cisse at the same time to give Stoke an outlet up front. The wing-backs dropped level with the centre-backs, the midfield two stayed in front of them, and Derby were left playing in front of a settled block.

Stoke still carried a threat on the break, and in the 84th minute Ben Johnson slid a pass across for Devenny, who could not get enough contact on his shot. That miss nearly cost them. In the 89th minute Ozoh drove low towards the corner and Johansson plunged to his right to push the shot away, the save that held the points.

Robins was clear afterwards about what his goalkeeper had given the side. “He’s been incredible and again there’s still improvement there and we’re looking at everything, but as a goalkeeper, as a human being, he’s absolutely outstanding, there’s none better,” he said, in quotes reported by the Press Association. “I don’t think there’s any better in this division and he proves that week in, week out, every day in training.”

Robins also admitted the performance carried a warning. “We gave the ball away too often and in one or two areas we looked tired but we dug out another three points,” he added. “I think we’d have gone under last year but we didn’t, we found the resilience to see the game out.”

The table and what comes next

The win lifts Stoke to sixth on 19 points from 11 games, inside the play-off places on a weekend when West Ham won at Swansea to stay second and West Brom beat Blackburn in another game shaped by a half-time midfield change. Derby stay 23rd on six points from 11 games, with nine goals scored and 20 conceded, and they are still waiting for a first home league win of the season.

Both sides play again on Saturday 24 October. Derby go to Sheffield United, and Stoke are at home to Bristol City.

Vikram Menon is a football analyst writing about Premier League tactics, data and transfers for The False 9.