Chicago Fire beat New York City FC 2-1 at Soldier Field on Saturday night, scoring twice while down to ten men to extend their winning run to three straight games and strengthen their push for second place in the Eastern Conference.

The Fire had to do it the hard way. New York City took a 19th-minute lead through Hannes Wolf’s fifth goal of the season, set up by Agustin Ojeda’s career-high 11th assist and Alonso Martinez’s first, in the winger’s first start of the season after his return from an ACL injury. Chicago then lost Dje D’Avilla to a second yellow card in the 43rd minute and faced nearly 50 minutes a man down. Few sides win league matches from that position. We previewed this as a must-win for Gregg Berhalter’s side, and they got it.

D’Avilla’s red card and the reshape

D’Avilla’s dismissal changed the contest completely. Trailing 1-0 with ten men, Chicago dropped into a compact, narrow shape, protected Chris Brady and stopped NYCFC finding space between the lines. The visitors had the ball but did very little with it. Their extra man brought no tempo and no sustained pressure, which allowed the Fire to stay within one goal until the break and reset at half time.

Brady made four saves across the 90 minutes and was the calmest man on the pitch during the spell Chicago were under most pressure. NYCFC’s failure to test him repeatedly with ten men on the pitch was the story of the second half.

Saletros heads the ten men level

The equaliser came in the 55th minute. Anton Saletros rose to head home his first goal in his first MLS season, with assists from Maren Haile-Selassie and Robert Lewandowski. It was Haile-Selassie’s career-best tenth assist of the campaign and Lewandowski’s third in his debut MLS season, and it rewarded Chicago’s decision to keep two outlets high even with ten men rather than retreat entirely.

At 1-1 the momentum sat with the home side despite the numbers. NYCFC had no answer to Chicago’s set-piece threat and kept conceding cheap fouls in wide areas, which is how a side with ten men ends up spending the last half hour attacking.

Haile-Selassie punishes Freese’s error

The winner arrived in the 87th minute and it was the night’s standout player who delivered it. Haile-Selassie pounced on a Matt Freese turnover and finished for his career-high ninth goal of the season, capping a night in which he had both created and scored Chicago’s goals. The winger signed a new contract with the Fire earlier this week after his career-best season.

Freese had made only two saves all night and his mistake was cruel on NYCFC, but the visitors had brought it on themselves. A team with an extra man for 47 minutes shouldn’t be gifting chances late on.

What it means: Fire chase second, NYCFC keep sliding

Chicago have now won three straight. Earlier they lost to Nashville and New England and drew with Inter Miami, three teams that started the day ahead of the fourth-place Fire. At 14-8-6 with a 9-4-1 home record, Berhalter’s side are now firmly in the race for second in the East. The season series with NYCFC is split after the visitors’ 3-1 win at home on July 25.

For NYCFC the picture is bleak. At 8-11-9 they began the day tenth in the East, have gone 1-5-5 since that July win over Chicago, and are 4-5-5 on the road. They travel to Inter Miami on Wednesday while Chicago host a Philadelphia Union side whose club-record unbeaten run reached 13 games with a 2-1 win over Real Salt Lake on Saturday.

Match timeline graphic: Chicago Fire 2-1 NYCFC, with Wolf's 19th-minute opener, D'Avilla's 43rd-minute red card, Saletros's 55th-minute equaliser and Haile-Selassie's 87th-minute winner

Tunde Bakare is a football writer covering the Premier League and African football, with a focus on tactics, transfers and the stories behind the game.