Updated Sunday 25 October, 20:58 UK
Michael Carrick’s Man Utd record across both his spells beats Ruben Amorim’s (13 wins in 28 games, 46.4%, against 38.1%) but sits well below Erik ten Hag’s and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s, both just over 54%. This is analysis: we’ve put figures from Sky Sports and the Premier League into one table after Sunday’s 3-0 home defeat by Bournemouth, United’s eighth game without a win.
Carrick vs Amorim stats in one table
| Manager | Games | W | D | L | Win % | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carrick (both spells) | 28 | 13 | 7 | 8 | 46.4 | Sky Sports, 22 May and 25 Oct (added up by us) |
| Carrick, interim spell | 16 | 11 | 3 | 2 | 68.8 | Sky Sports, 22 May 2026 |
| Carrick, this season | 12 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 16.7 | Sky Sports, 25 Oct 2026 |
| Amorim | 63 | 24 | 18* | 21 | 38.1 | Sky Sports, 6 Jan 2026 |
| Ten Hag | 128 | 70 | 23* | 35 | 54.7 | Premier League, 29 Oct 2024; Premier League, 5 Jan 2026 |
| Solskjaer | 168 | 91 | 37 | 40 | 54.2 | Sky Sports, 22 Nov 2021 |
* Draws worked out as games minus wins and losses. Win % is wins divided by games.
How we’ve counted Carrick
Amorim was sacked on 5 January 2026 and Carrick was appointed interim head coach later that month. Sky Sports reported on 22 May that he’d won 11, drawn three and lost two of 16 games, the day United confirmed a two-year deal. This season, Sky’s results list on 25 October shows two wins, four draws and six defeats in 12 games.
We’ve added the two together, because it’s one man in one job and the other managers’ figures run from first game to last. That gives 13 wins, seven draws and eight defeats. Counting only the interim spell would flatter him, and counting only this season would ignore the 16 games that earned him the job.
Sky’s results lists for Carrick don’t spell out which competitions they cover, while the other managers’ figures are all competitions. Draws for Amorim and Ten Hag aren’t stated in the pages we opened, so we’ve worked them out from the totals. Percentages are ours or the outlet’s as shown, and none of this adjusts for squad strength, fixtures or the number of cup ties.
Carrick vs Amorim
Amorim won 24 of 63 games, a 38.1% rate that the Premier League’s analysis of his reign on 5 January put lowest of the permanent managers it listed. In the league, it gave him 15 wins and 19 defeats from 47 games, at 1.23 points per game.
Over a full tenure, Carrick is clearly ahead. This season it flips. His seven points from eight Premier League games (one win, four draws, three defeats, per the same Sky list) work out at 0.88 a game, below Amorim’s career average.
Carrick against Ten Hag and Solskjaer
Ten Hag won 70 of 128 games, and the Premier League’s review of his reign on 29 October 2024 had him on 44 wins and 27 defeats from 85 league games, 1.72 points a game. Sky Sports put Solskjaer on 91 wins, 37 draws and 40 defeats from 168 games when he was sacked in November 2021. His league average over 109 games was 1.81, per the Premier League’s January table.
Carrick’s 46.4% is about eight points below both. His interim spell, at 68.8%, beat everyone in the table, but 16 games is a small sample. We’d argue the fairer verdict is that he’s better than Amorim and worse than Ten Hag and Solskjaer. That spell is why the overall figure looks respectable, and the 16.7% this season is why United are 16th.
Where Carrick stands
He hasn’t been sacked and the club hasn’t announced anything. Sky Sports’ Rob Dorsett reported on Sunday that his future is “hanging by a thread” and that club insiders expect him to be relieved of his duties, with Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada due to make a recommendation to Sir Jim Ratcliffe. Sky named Julian Nagelsmann and Eddie Howe as the expected front-runners if he goes.
More on that in our posts on whether United will sack Carrick, the next manager, Howe and Nagelsmann.
What happens next
Chelsea v Man Utd is on Saturday 31 October at 12:30 UK.
Frequently asked
What is Carrick’s record as Man Utd manager?
Adding Sky Sports’ figures for his interim spell and this season gives 28 games, 13 wins, seven draws and eight defeats, a 46.4% win rate.
Is Carrick’s record better than Amorim’s?
Overall, yes: 46.4% against Amorim’s 38.1% from the Premier League and Sky figures. This season his 0.88 points per league game trails Amorim’s 1.23 career average.
What was Amorim’s Man Utd record?
He won 24 of 63 games, lost 21 and had a 38.1% win rate, according to Sky Sports on 6 January 2026.
Featured photo: Timmy96, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (cropped).








Discussion
Is Carrick's record better or worse than Amorim's when you look at the numbers? Tell us below.
No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.