Alejandro Balde has played 12 minutes of La Liga football this season. Barcelona’s 22-year-old left-back, a Spain international and one of the fastest defenders in Europe, has gone from regular starter to bystander under Hansi Flick. Now other clubs are interested: Liverpool and Manchester United have both been sounded out over a January move, Juventus are plotting a loan swoop, and Barcelona have given his representatives permission to explore an exit. It could be one of the more interesting deals of the winter window.

The 12-Minute Man: How Flick Froze Out Barcelona’s Flying Left-Back

Balde has played 12 La Liga minutes for Barcelona this season, and, as Liverpool.com reported on 4 October 2026, he was left out of Barcelona’s squad entirely at the weekend. For a player who was once a fixture on the left at the Camp Nou, it has been a rapid fall.

The tactical picture under Hansi Flick is clear. The German coach has reshaped Barcelona’s full-back positions into something closer to inverted midfielders than overlapping wing-backs, and the new pecking order at left-back is clear: Xavi Espart and Joao Cancelo are ahead of Balde, with Gerard Martin also preferred in recent weeks. TEAMtalk’s report on 3 October, relayed by The Hard Tackle, notes Balde has managed just one first-team appearance all season and has also lost his place in the Spain squad.

This is not a player in decline but one who no longer fits the system. Balde’s game is built on explosive sprints, the classic overlapping left-back profile, and Flick’s system has moved on without him. Barcelona’s willingness to let a La Masia graduate of this quality go shows how hard-headed the current rebuild is: this is the same board that, as covered in our tactical breakdown of Chelsea’s £51m Koundé raid, is prepared to listen to significant offers for senior defenders in order to fund the next phase.

Embed from Getty Images

The January Bombshell: United and Liverpool ‘Sounded Out’

According to TEAMtalk’s 3 October report, Balde’s representatives have been given permission by Barcelona to explore options away from the Camp Nou, and they have already sounded out both Liverpool and Manchester United over a potential January move. Manchester United, specifically, have been spoken to about a January loan, while Liverpool have been offered the opportunity to sign the defender.

This is more than recycled summer gossip. The details have firmed up in the last 72 hours. Liverpool.com’s 4 October update confirms the player has struggled for game time (12 La Liga minutes, left out of the squad at the weekend) and, importantly, that Barcelona are “keen to move the 22-year-old on.” The Catalan club’s stance has shifted from persuade him to stay and fight to actively facilitate his departure, with the Blaugrana believing he is valued at roughly €60 million (£51m) that could be reinvested into the squad.

BBC Sport’s Tuesday gossip column on 5 October added the final ingredient: Juventus, via Calciomercato, are also in the race for Balde, making this a three-club scramble for a 22-year-old Spain international whose deal runs to 2028.

Alejandro Balde's per-90 attacking numbers compared with Liverpool's Milos Kerkez, Manchester United's Luke Shaw and Juventus' Andrea Cambiaso

Why Iraola’s Liverpool Want Him: The Kerkez Problem

Liverpool’s interest is the easiest to explain on the pitch. Andoni Iraola’s 4-2-3-1 is built on high-tempo width: full-backs are expected to overlap aggressively, pin opposition wingers, and deliver quality into a box crowded with runners. It is, on paper, a system designed for a player like Balde.

The problem is the man currently in the shirt. Milos Kerkez has not kicked on since joining from Bournemouth, struggling to hit the heights that made him one of the Premier League’s most coveted left-backs. Kerkez did at least find the net for Hungary during the international break, as covered in our takeaways from Liverpool’s wild fortnight, but one goal does not fix a structural problem: Liverpool’s left flank has been a soft underbelly all season.

Behind Kerkez, the depth is thin. Kostas Tsimikas is out of contract at the end of the season and has barely featured. Liverpool.com’s analysis is direct: the position has been identified as one the Reds want to reinforce in January. Balde offers what Iraola’s system demands: recovery pace for a high line, the ability to beat players one-on-one, and crossing range to feed Isak and the inside forwards. His ceiling is arguably as high as any left-back in the league.

Embed from Getty Images

The question is whether Liverpool would guarantee him minutes, because Balde will not swap one bench for another. With Kerkez struggling and Tsimikas fading, there is a real opportunity.

Why Carrick’s United Are Desperate: The Left-Back Void

If Liverpool’s interest is logical, Manchester United’s is more urgent. Michael Carrick’s 4-2-3-1 has a clear gap at left-back. Luke Shaw is United’s only recognised senior left-back, and the club has already shown its intentions: United already lead the £25m race for Crystal Palace’s Tyrick Mitchell, as we broke down last month, which shows Carrick considers the position a January priority regardless of Balde.

The deeper problem is what happened to Patrick Dorgu. The Dane has been repositioned further forward, leaving United with a single senior option in a role that demands enormous athletic output in Carrick’s system. Opposition wingers have found plenty of space on United’s left all season, and with the club chasing the top four, January reinforcements are a necessity.

Tactically, Balde is arguably a better fit for Carrick than for anyone else. Carrick wants his full-backs to overlap at pace and combine with the left-sided winger in 2v1 overloads; Balde’s sprint speed, among the top five per cent of full-backs in Europe, suits that pattern. A January loan with an option to buy, as TEAMtalk report United have discussed, would be a low-risk trial: six months to prove he can handle the Premier League’s physicality before United commit €60m.

The Juventus Curveball: Calciomercato’s Loan Plan

There is also an Italian option. Calciomercato’s reporting, carried by BBC Sport’s gossip column, has Juventus planning a January loan move for Balde, and for a 22-year-old who has barely played all season, Turin could be a sensible career move.

Juventus’ logic is obvious. Their new sporting structure under Carnevali is targeting young, resale-value defenders, and a loan with an option lets them test Balde in a league that rewards tactical intelligence over raw physicality. Serie A’s slower tempo and emphasis on positional discipline could be the perfect rehabilitation environment for a player whose confidence has been shredded by months on the bench.

For Barcelona, a loan to Juventus also makes commercial sense: it rebuilds Balde’s market value ahead of a definitive summer sale.

The Five Obstacles: Why This Deal Could Still Die

1. Balde doesn’t want to leave. This is the big one. Marca report the 22-year-old remains unwilling to change his mind, believing he can still win back minutes at the Camp Nou. A player who refuses to agitate is a player who rarely moves in January.

2. The €60m valuation. Liverpool.com report Barcelona value him at roughly €60m, a huge fee for a player with 12 La Liga minutes this season. Liverpool have other priorities and United prefer a loan, so a full-price January deal looks unlikely.

3. Barcelona’s contract leverage. Balde’s deal runs to 2028, so Barcelona are under no pressure to sell cheaply. They can wait for their price, which points to long negotiations rather than a quick deal.

4. Getting back into the Spain squad. Balde has already lost his place with Spain. Any move must guarantee minutes if he wants to win it back, which narrows the field to clubs offering a real starting role. That is why Liverpool’s Kerkez problem might matter more than United’s money.

5. The competition could inflate everything. With three clubs interested and under three months until the window opens, the fee and wages could rise if Liverpool, United and Juventus all firm up their interest, and Barcelona may simply keep him as depth.

The Verdict: 8.7/10 — The Signing Liverpool Need, the Gamble United Want

The fit is clearest at Anfield. Liverpool 8.7/10: Iraola’s system is built for a player with Balde’s profile, the left-back position is the weakest in the squad, and there is a real chance of starting. He would fix a weakness in a title-challenging squad.

Manchester United 8.4/10: the need is arguably greater, but the Mitchell pursuit complicates things, as United are unlikely to sign two left-backs in January. A loan would be shrewd business, but only if Carrick guarantees Balde the starting shirt.

Juventus 7.9/10: the smartest rehabilitation project, but the weakest pull. Balde wants the Premier League; Turin is plan B.

Stay at Barcelona 5.8/10: loyalty is admirable, but 12 minutes in half a season is a career going backwards. In a World Cup year, sentiment is not a strategy.

Balde could still fight his way back at the Camp Nou, but a January move looks more likely.

Arjun Rao is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactical breakdowns, transfer analysis and the numbers behind the game.