Manchester United travel to the Riyadh Air Metropolitano on Tuesday night for the hardest test of their Champions League campaign so far: Atletico Madrid, second in La Liga, in a Matchday 2 tie that kicks off at 8pm BST. United beat Sabah 4-0 on the opening night, but with Saturday’s El Sackico against Tottenham coming first and an injury list that stretched to ten names this week, Michael Carrick faces five selection gambles before a ball is kicked in Madrid.

Tale of the tape: Atletico Madrid vs Manchester United, Champions League Matchday 2

Carrick’s five selection gambles

1. The full-back crisis. Patrick Dorgu is a hamstring doubt after Denmark duty and Noussair Mazraoui picked up an impact injury with Morocco, according to LiveScore’s injury audit published on Thursday. Our view: Mazraoui’s knock is the likelier to clear, so he starts at right-back, while young Diego Leon, who featured in the behind-closed-doors win over Lausanne-Sport, gets the nod at left-back if Dorgu fails his test. As we set out in our El Sackico predicted lineups, this is the area of the pitch Carrick can least afford to get wrong.

2. De Ligt’s bench return. Matthijs de Ligt is back in first-team training after his back surgery, and the Manchester Evening News reports he has an outside chance of the Spurs squad, with a place on the bench against Atletico Madrid or Como in the Champions League the likelier route back, via The Peoples Person. We expect him among the substitutes in Madrid rather than thrown straight into Simeone’s press.

3. Baleba’s first start. The £70m summer signing from Brighton got his first minutes in a United shirt in that 2-1 closed-doors win over Lausanne-Sport on 2 October. As we detailed last week, his ball-winning gives Carrick’s 4-2-3-1 the legs it has lacked. Madrid away is a demanding place for a full debut, but United’s midfield has been overrun too often this season for Carrick to leave him out again. He starts.

4. Mainoo’s fitness. Kobbie Mainoo is listed as a doubt with an unspecified knock, and with Manuel Ugarte out with a knee injury, Carrick’s pivot options are thin. Our view is that Mainoo comes through and partners Baleba, because the alternative is reshaping the whole midfield three days before a European away night.

5. The attacking doubts. Benjamin Sesko (shin), Marcus Rashford (hip) and Amad Diallo (ankle) are all doubts. Bruno Fernandes played through a hip niggle for Portugal and scored on the opening night against Sabah, so he starts at No.10 regardless. We expect Carrick to risk Sesko through the middle if he trains on Monday, with Matheus Cunha the ready-made alternative after his lively start to the season.

Carrick was measured after the 1-1 draw at Fulham that left United 12th with five points from five: “It has been pretty fine margins [so far this season] that have flipped it [the wrong way],” he told reporters at Craven Cottage, via LiveScore. “I know we can do better.” Two wins from seven in all competitions, per Opta Analyst, says the margins are starting to wear thin.

Simeone’s three calls

Atletico’s situation is far healthier. Diego Simeone’s side are second in La Liga with five wins from their first seven games, according to TribalFootball, and they visit Alaves on Saturday before United arrive. But the Argentine has three decisions of his own.

Grimaldo’s race. Alex Grimaldo felt a quad twinge warming up with Spain and was sent home from international duty for tests. Marca’s reporting, via Into the Calderon, is cautiously optimistic: he may sit out Alaves so he is ready for United. We expect him to make it.

The Barrios void. Pablo Barrios is out after injuring his right leg in the Matchday 1 defeat at Liverpool, and he will miss Alaves too. Marcos Llorente and Morten Hjulmand continue as the central pair, which keeps Atletico’s 3-4-2-1 compact but removes Barrios’ legs from the press.

The striker question. Julian Alvarez missed games in September with a muscle overload and his future has dominated the noise around the club, with TEAMtalk reporting he is set to switch agents amid talk of an Arsenal move in January, as covered in our gossip column. Jonathan David, on loan this summer, has scored in his first two La Liga appearances and is the form pick. Alexander Sorloth is back in training but yet to play a minute this season. Our view: David starts, with Alvarez and Sorloth as second-half options.

Predicted XIs

Atletico Madrid (3-4-2-1): Oblak; Hancko, Le Normand, Romero; Giuliano Simeone, Llorente, Hjulmand, Grimaldo; Baena, Lee Kang-in; David.

Manchester United (4-2-3-1): Lammens; Mazraoui, Martinez, Maguire, Leon; Baleba, Mainoo; Amad, Fernandes, Rashford; Sesko.

Senne Lammens is undisputed as United’s No.1 after Karl Darlow’s summer arrival as back-up, with Andre Onana and Altay Bayindir both out on loan. All selections are conditional on Saturday: El Sackico comes first, and any fresh damage at Old Trafford reshuffles this side.

Three tactical battles

United’s makeshift full-backs vs Simeone’s wing-backs. If Leon starts his first senior game at the Metropolitano, expect Giuliano Simeone to run at him all night, with Grimaldo overlapping on the other flank. Carrick may ask his wide midfielders to sit deeper than usual.

The second-ball fight. Baleba ranked in the top one per cent for second balls won in his final Brighton season. Against Llorente and Hjulmand, who squeeze the middle of the pitch in Simeone’s 3-4-2-1, United’s season could hinge on whether their new pivot wins that duel.

David’s movement vs Martinez and Maguire. David has made a habit of drifting into the channel between centre-back and wing-back. Lisandro Martinez reads that run well, but Harry Maguire turning against a mobile striker is the mismatch Simeone will target. The last meeting between these clubs, a 1-0 Atletico win at Old Trafford in the 2022 round of 16, was decided by exactly that kind of run.

Prediction

Atletico have lost only at Liverpool in Europe and are flying domestically; United have won twice in seven and are held together by fitness tests. As noted in our Champions League Matchday 2 preview, Atletico have never beaten an English side in the league phase, which has to end somewhere. Our view: the Metropolitano ends it. Atletico Madrid 2-1 Manchester United.

United then travel to Como on 21 October for Matchday 3, while Atletico go to Stuttgart the night before. For Carrick, though, everything depends on Saturday first: El Sackico kicks off at 5.30pm at Old Trafford, and defeat there would make Tuesday feel even longer.

Arjun Rao is a football writer covering the Premier League for The False 9 — tactical breakdowns, transfer analysis and the numbers behind the game.